Comparative property ratings for major tool steel families. Ratings reflect general performance characteristics and are intended as a guide for material selection.
Water Hardening Tool Steel
| SAE Steel Designation | Non-Deforming Properties | Safety in Hardening | Depth of Hardening | Toughness | Resistance to Softening Effect of Heat | Wear Resistance | Machinability |
|---|
| W108 | Poor | Fair | Shallow | Good (b) | Poor | Fair | Best |
| W109 | Poor | Fair | Shallow | Good (b) | Poor | Fair | Best |
| W110 | Poor | Fair | Shallow | Good (b) | Poor | Good | Best |
| W112 | Poor | Fair | Shallow | Good (b) | Poor | Good | Best |
| W209 | Poor | Fair | Shallow | Good | Poor | Fair | Best |
| W210 | Poor | Fair | Shallow | Good | Poor | Good | Best |
| W310 | Poor | Fair | Shallow | Good | Poor | Good | Best |
Shock Resisting Tool Steel
| SAE Steel Designation | Non-Deforming Properties | Safety in Hardening | Depth of Hardening | Toughness | Resistance to Softening Effect of Heat | Wear Resistance | Machinability |
|---|
| S1 Chrome Tungsten | Fair | Good | Medium | Good | Fair | Fair | Fair |
| S2 Silicon Molybdenum | W Poor (c) | W Poor (c) | Medium | Best | Fair | Fair | Good |
| S5 Silicon Manganese | W Poor (c) | W Poor (c) | Medium | Best | Fair | Fair | Fair |
Oil Hardening Types
| SAE Steel Designation | Non-Deforming Properties | Safety in Hardening | Depth of Hardening | Toughness | Resistance to Softening Effect of Heat | Wear Resistance | Machinability |
|---|
| O1 Low Manganese | Good | Good | Medium | Fair | Poor | Good | Good |
| O2 High Manganese | Good | Good | Medium | Fair | Poor | Good | Good |
| O6 Molybdenum Graphitic | Fair | Good | Medium | Fair | Poor | Good | Best |
Medium Alloy Air Hardening Types
| SAE Steel Designation | Non-Deforming Properties | Safety in Hardening | Depth of Hardening | Toughness | Resistance to Softening Effect of Heat | Wear Resistance | Machinability |
|---|
| A2-5% Chrome Air Hard | Best | Best | Deep | Fair | Fair | Good | Fair |
High Carbon — High Chrome Types
| SAE Steel Designation | Non-Deforming Properties | Safety in Hardening | Depth of Hardening | Toughness | Resistance to Softening Effect of Heat | Wear Resistance | Machinability |
|---|
| D2 — High Carbon High Chrome (Air) | Best | Best | Deep | Fair | Fair | Best | Poor |
| D3 — High Carbon High Chrome (Oil) | Good | Good | Deep | Poor | Fair | Best | Poor |
| D5 — High Carbon High Chrome Cobalt | Best | Best | Deep | Fair | Fair | Best | Poor |
| D7 — High Carbon High Chrome High Vanadium | Best | Best | Deep | Poor | Fair | Best | Poor |
Chrome Base Types
| SAE Steel Designation | Non-Deforming Properties | Safety in Hardening | Depth of Hardening | Toughness | Resistance to Softening Effect of Heat | Wear Resistance | Machinability |
|---|
| H11 Chrome Molybdenum V | Good | Good | Deep | Good | Good | Fair | Fair |
| H12 Chrome Molybdenum | Good | Good | Deep | Good | Good | Fair | Fair |
| H13 Chrome Molybdenum VV | Good | Good | Deep | Good | Good | Fair | Fair |
Tungsten Base Types
| SAE Steel Designation | Non-Deforming Properties | Safety in Hardening | Depth of Hardening | Toughness | Resistance to Softening Effect of Heat | Wear Resistance | Machinability |
|---|
| H21 Tungsten | Good | Good | Deep | Good | Good | Fair | Fair |
Tungsten Base Types 2
| SAE Steel Designation | Non-Deforming Properties | Safety in Hardening | Depth of Hardening | Toughness | Resistance to Softening Effect of Heat | Wear Resistance | Machinability |
|---|
| T1 Tungsten 18-4-1 | Good | Good | Deep | Poor | Good | Good | Fair |
| T2 Tungsten 18-4-2 | Good | Good | Deep | Poor | Good | Good | Fair |
| T4 Cobalt Tungsten 18-4-1-5 | Good | Fair | Deep | Poor | Best | Good | Fair |
| T5 Cobalt Tungsten 18-4-2-8 | Good | Fair | Deep | Poor | Best | Good | Fair |
| T8 Cobalt Tungsten 18-4-2-5 | Good | Fair | Deep | Poor | Best | Good | Fair |
Molybdenum Base Types
| SAE Steel Designation | Non-Deforming Properties | Safety in Hardening | Depth of Hardening | Toughness | Resistance to Softening Effect of Heat | Wear Resistance | Machinability |
|---|
| M1 Molybdenum 8-2-1 | Good | Fair | Deep | Poor | Good | Good | Fair |
| M2 Molybdenum Tungsten 6-6-2 | Good | Fair | Deep | Poor | Good | Good | Fair |
| M3 Molybdenum Tungsten 6-6-3 | Good | Fair | Deep | Poor | Good | Best | Fair |
| M4 Molybdenum Tungsten 6-6-4 | Good | Fair | Deep | Poor | Good | Best | Fair |
Low Alloy Types
| SAE Steel Designation | Non-Deforming Properties | Safety in Hardening | Depth of Hardening | Toughness | Resistance to Softening Effect of Heat | Wear Resistance | Machinability |
|---|
| L6 Nickel Chrome | Fair | Good | Medium | Fair | Poor | Fair | Fair |
| L7 Chrome | Fair | Good | Medium | Fair | Poor | Good | Fair |
(a) Depth of hardening depends on section size and quench severity.
(b) Toughness decreases as carbon content increases.
(c) W = Water quench required.